Little Boxes
Brooklyn Heights, New York is considered to be the first suburb in America. It's a 5 minute subway ride to Wall St, and overlooks well...well it overlooks things. Views of the East River, the Brooklyn Bridge and Manhattan skyline are within walking distance and some of the architecture dates back to when Washington walked the streets. The picture to the left is not Brooklyn Heights. It is Denver Colorado.
I grew up in Oshawa, ON. On a recent visit home, and a long walk up to another placed called Brooklin, just north of 'Shwa, I rediscovered that not only is the spelling different, the idea of the suburb is yes, very different from the age of founding fathers. I also rediscovered years of vitriol I have layed upon the 'burbs. The plague that is the desert of prefab sterility so many of us call home seems unending, even with the end of oil just coming over the horizon, urban planners, city councils, developers and new families are hell bent on continuing what is a proven broken model of human organization. Brooklin, ON is a cute little town surrounded by a patchwork of overgrown wooden weeds. Housing developments have sprung up almost at random and seem like some horizontal monolithic monster on the edge of consuming whole the once quaint small town Ontario community.
The white signs of 'progress' are everywhere. These civil little signs, dutifully placed in accordance to law appear in communities everywhere but no one really notices them. In the case of southern Ontario, there is usually a corresponding boarded up farm house on the property, as another family business responsible for generations of local food production and local employment dies. It's a tired conversation over a lot of dinner tables now. "We're paving over the best farmland in the world to put up another gas station?!?". Does Royal Bank really need branch number 445 right here, on this field? With another Mac's, a tired old sports bar, that'll go out of business within a year to be replaced by another tired old bar and grill which will be next to another Dollarama.
The walk to Brooklin also reminded me of Jesse's fear of the suburbs. He actually gets Ill. It's natural living proof of how the suburbs are antithetical to our nature. For someone like Jess, who lived in small communities in Taz and then in the brilliant big cities in Australia, to see him drive through a 'new community' is funny and frightening as it fills him with anxiety and nausea.
There's an inherent disconnect in the suburbs, and the newer model called exurbs. These are commuter towns, with no core, no old business district and are built with more attention paid to the highway leading in and out of the city than travel within the city. They are in many cases even further from the city of working destination for it's inhabitants than older suburbs, and people unlucky enough to get work in the exurbs, are usually employed in a service job, low-skilled manufacturing or high-tech. Boxes that people work in boxes to pay for the boxes that they live in.
The in-betweeness. Of something not finished. Exurbs exude this in their design, and feeling. They are hollow in the centre with no attention to the details of life like parks, functional walking based shopping districts, schools you can walk to, and landscaping. The community centres are in most cases private facilities and you 'd be hard-pressed to find any municipal buildings within them as the governing of cities has centralized to the point of absurdity.
There seems to be no end in site to this. In fact, the exurb model of continued growth outwards and creating new cities based on what is offered to developers by local governments in terms of tax breaks and sweet land deals is going to go ahead unabated. Building up and renewing our old cities, which were built in a time of community needs and linkages that didn't rely on the car as transport does not seem to be the preferred model.There are amazing case study cities that have bucked the trend in recent decades and are starting to reap the rewards of better health and prosperity. Portland, Oregon, Pittsburgh, Penn. Boston, Mass. San Francisco and in Canada, Quebec City has been mentioned as a example.
Urban renewal, which used to be a couple of dirty words is being reviewed through the prism of greening our cities. If new development and revitalization is framed by what is best for the environment in a lot of cases it proves to be better for human organization as well.
There is always a better way. In how we choose to live amongst one another, it seems we have decided to choose the least human and natural imperatives to guide our city's developments. Take a drive on a nice summer day to place like Niagara on the Lake Ontario, or Cambridge Mass. or to Whistler in the winter, or Port Perry Ontario during Christmas, you'll see countless foreign plates and strange faces looking in awe and comforted wonder but also with a tinge of jealousy toward the natives. We favour closeness and convenience in so much of our personal lives, we design technologies to make it simpler for life but we have made our great cities mere places to live. They are so unattractive and unlivable, the opposite of what we desire in our hearts. Your home is the largest single investment you will make both in terms of money but also on the impact it has on the design of your life, the friends you meet, the family that comes to visit, the state of your health, the happiness of your marriage, the safety and development of your children are all dependent on this decision. If we start to ask ourselves as individuals and families what is best for my needs outside of the pocketbook, and what is a better way to live, the home we buy and the piece of earth it occupies should be at the top of the list.